
What We Did Not Know: The Aftermath of Thirty Years of Legal Abortion
Who could have predicted the bitter fruit and tragedy that would come from legalized abortion? After thirty years, the aftermath demands examination.
by Carrie Gordon Earll
When the movement
to repeal laws banning abortion began to take shape in the late 1960’s,
abortion proponents were on the verge of propelling the U.S. into
uncharted territory. Never before in the nation’s history had abortion
been available on demand and for practically any reason during the
entire term of pregnancy. Few prognosticators could predict what
widespread and unrestrained abortion would mean in terms of social
policy, let alone women’s health. Two landmark U.S. Supreme Court
rulings, Roe vs. Wade and Doe vs. Bolton, opened the floodgates and
now, thirty-plus years later, Americans taste the bitter fruit of Roe
and Doe legacy.
For more, see Abortion Law in the United States.
What do we know now about the impact of abortion that we did not know when it was legalized in 1973?
We did not know that the number of abortions performed nationally would skyrocket.
- The
number of reported abortions in the U.S. more than doubled in the first
two decades after legalization, reaching more than one million each
year.
We did not know that promises of less child abuse and fewer out-of-wedlock births were false.
- After
legalization, the reported number of child abuse cases quadrupled and
the number of births to unmarried women more than tripled.
We did not know about the prevalence of repeat abortions.
- In 1999, 45 percent of women who had abortions in the U.S. had at least one previous abortion.
We
did not know that the vast majority of abortions would be for reasons
other than rape, incest and the life of the mother, or that most would
be among single women.
- These hard case categories
represent approximately 1 percent of all U.S. abortions. Two-thirds of
all abortions are among never-married women.
We
did not know that abortion advocates would knowingly exaggerate the
number of illegal abortion deaths prior to 1973 in order to boost their
political case for repealing abortion prohibitions.
- You’ve
probably heard that tens of thousand of American women died in illegal
abortions before 1973, the year that abortion was legalized in all 50
states. Bernard Nathanson, an early leader in the abortion rights
movement and an abortionist for many years, tells a different story in
this excerpt from his book, Aborting America: How many deaths were we
talking about when abortion was illegal? In N.A.R.A.L. (The National
Abortion Rights Action League) we generally emphasized the drama of the
individual case, not the mass statistics, but when we spoke of the
latter is was always ‘5,000 to 10,000 deaths a year.’ I confess that I
knew the figures were totally false, and I suppose the others did too
if they stopped to think of it. But in the ‘morality’ of our
revolution, it was a useful figure, widely accepted, so why go out of
our way to correct it with honest statistics.
- Nathanson’s
admission of purposefully padding the abortion death numbers is
confirmed by fellow early abortion advocate Lucinda Cisler, writing
before legalization in 1973: Another statistic that is bandied about
for all the right reasons – but with much unwarranted confidence – is
the figure of 10,000 U.S. abortion deaths per year. A study made in the
1930’s, before the development of antibiotics made even illegal
abortion less deadly than it used to be, came up with this number of
10,000 deaths; but it is no longer anywhere near the truth and has no
place in any serious discussion about abortion. The most accurate
estimates are that 500-1,000 deaths occur each year because of septic
abortions, and this range takes false reporting strongly into account.
We did not know the physical and mental health risks associated with abortion.
- Women
face a number of possible physical complications including hemorrhage
requiring transfusion, perforation of the uterus, cardiac arrest, major
unintended surgery, infection resulting in hospitalization,
convulsions, undiagnosed ectopic (tubal) pregnancy, cervical
laceration, uterine rupture, and death.
- All
women, especially young teenagers, are at risk for damage to their
cervix during an abortion, which can lead to complications with later
pregnancies.
- A
Finnish study of suicide after pregnancy found that the suicide rate
after an abortion was three times the general suicide rate and six
times that associated with birth.
- Women
who ended their first pregnancy by abortion are five times more likely
to report subsequent substance abuse than women who carried the
pregnancy to term, and four times more likely to report substance abuse
compared to those whose first pregnancy ended naturally.
(For more, see Abortion Complications.)
We did not know that abortionists would develop barbaric late-term abortion methods, such as partial-birth abortion.
- Partial-birth abortion involves the partial delivery of a living child in order to puncture and crush the baby’s skull.
We did not know that medical advances would allow physicians to perform surgery on preborn children in the womb.
We
did not know that developments in obstetric imaging resulting in
4D-ultrasound technology would allow us to come face to face with
preborn children before birth.
We
did not know that the two women listed as plaintiffs in the U.S.
Supreme Court cases that resulted in legalized abortion, Roe v. Wade
and Doe v. Bolton, would later regret their involvement and ask that
these landmark cases be reversed.
Now three decades and more than 40 million abortions later we know!